The conversation
The Power of Plot: David Reimer on Moving Narratives
Narrative strategist David Reimer discusses how founders can treat storytelling as a foundational tool for finding product-market fit rather than just a marketing layer. He shares advice on why the customer—not the product—must always be the protagonist, how to weave data into emotional arcs to make metrics stick, and why the ultimate core of any memorable brand narrative relies on uncovering raw human motivation.
6Degrees
David Reimer’s work sits at the intersection of storytelling, entrepreneurship, and human psychology. Asked what emerging questions excite him most, his answer is immediate: artificial intelligence.
David Reimer
The question that I get nowadays is how can AI help with storytelling?
6Degrees
While AI can accelerate structure and craft, Reimer is clear about its limits.
David Reimer
It’s certainly not going to replace their role in telling the story, the human’s role in telling the story.
6Degrees
For him, the promise of AI lies in assistance, not authorship. Reimer emphasizes that tools like chatbots can generate narratives, but only humans can uncover the insight that matters most.
David Reimer
Any chatbot can help you put together…a potential narrative, but you need to have the smart strategic inputs and you need to understand the great customer insights…that are at the core of the story.
6Degrees
Authenticity, he insists, comes from lived experience.
David Reimer
It can help us with all sorts of structural things…but it can’t make an authentic story.
6Degrees
That belief underpins his approach to teaching founders how to think about narrative as a strategic tool rather than a cosmetic layer. At the center of every effective story, Reimer argues, is motivation.
David Reimer
At the core of every great story is some human motivation and discovering it takes some work.
6Degrees
This is why he encourages founders to collaborate with AI, not outsource judgment to it.
David Reimer
There’s a place for both the human still in the equation…and the tool.
6Degrees
Reimer structures startup storytelling around growth phases that mirror a classic narrative arc. Early on, story is inseparable from product–market fit.
David Reimer
The narrative structure…is a strategic tool that teaches you as the creator how to figure out that first product market fit.
6Degrees
Questions about who the customer is, what problem matters most, and why a solution is better than existing alternatives are not just marketing concerns—they are foundational design decisions. As founders test assumptions, the story evolves with them. Where many teams stumble, Reimer notes, is attachment to their first idea.
David Reimer
People get stuck in their own biases. They fall in love with their original story and their original story isn’t always the right story.
6Degrees
He points to founders who learned to listen closely to customers and pivot when a different, more urgent narrative emerged. The discipline of storytelling, in this sense, becomes a way of vetting one’s worldview against reality. A recurring theme in Reimer’s thinking is that the customer—not the product—must be the protagonist. When founders lead with features, he stops them.
David Reimer
I just stop them in the middle of their sentence and I say why should I care about that?
6Degrees
Stories only work when they center a real person with a real struggle.
David Reimer
If they think about their customer as a human and not an entity…it’s so much easier to get at that human motivator.
6Degrees
To uncover that motivator, Reimer urges founders to act like journalists or therapists, repeatedly asking why. He illustrates this with a simple heuristic: keep asking “what do you really want?” until something memorable emerges.
David Reimer
Every time she asks him…she’s getting closer to the truth.
6Degrees
You know you’ve reached the core when you hear something and think,
David Reimer
That’s something I’d remember.
6Degrees
Emotion, for Reimer, is not the enemy of rigor—it is its ally. He explains this through neuroscience, noting that emotion and memory are tightly linked.
David Reimer
Our brains have literally evolved to respond to story. When something moves us, we get a dopamine hit…effectively putting a post-it note in your brain that says remember this.
6Degrees
Ignoring emotion, he argues, is an irrational choice for anyone trying to persuade. This doesn’t mean abandoning data. Instead, Reimer advocates weaving metrics into narrative. The goal is not volume but resonance.
David Reimer
Pick the right data points…the few data points that illustrate the problem or the solution—and embed them in a story people can visualize.
6Degrees
Done well, the number sticks because the narrative carries it. Across startups and Fortune 500 companies alike, Reimer sees enduring continuity. Tools change, but the fundamentals remain.
David Reimer
There’s still magic in going out and talking to human beings.
6Degrees
Watching reactions, listening carefully, and probing for meaning are as necessary now as they were decades ago. AI may accelerate the process, but it cannot replace the human work of understanding. Ultimately, Reimer frames storytelling not as embellishment but as strategy. A compelling narrative helps people grasp a problem, “almost feel it in their bones,” and only then does the business case matter.
David Reimer
If I don’t believe there’s a customer with a problem and that it’s a really big problem…none of the rest of the stuff matters.